FHFA Releases Paper on Changing MSR Fees, Wants More Input

Mortgage & Real Estate

The Federal Housing Finance Agency Tuesday afternoon released a 37-page “talking paper” on changing GSE servicing fees, while noting that GNMA compensation – for now – will not be part of the discussion.

Like what you see? Click here to sign up for a National Mortgage News free trial and daily newsletter to get the latest feature stories, news headlines, data, and in-depth analysis on the issues impacting the mortgage industry.

“Because Ginnie Mae differs from the Enterprises in its model, powers and limitations, any change to servicing compensation or to servicer risk exposure” would have to be examined by the Government National Mortgage Association, which is part of HUD.

FHFA, as part of a joint initiative with the Department of Housing and Urban Development, is now seeking comment on two GSE-only compensation models, after first floating the idea of change back in February.

Currently, servicers processing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans are paid a minimum of 25 basis points of the loan amount.

In its talking paper, FHFA once again floats the idea of paying a set dollar amount for servicing loans, while keeping open to the idea of maintaining a minimum servicing fee model similar to the current structure, but one with a reserve account option. “The reserve account would be available to offset unexpectedly high servicing costs resulting from extraordinary deteriorations in industry conditions,” the talking paper notes.

The government seems to be leaning toward a new model that in particular addresses the servicing of delinquent loans, offering a higher fee structure, but some mortgage bankers believe this might actually incentivize servicers to allow borderline loans to go into arrears because it would trigger higher processing fees.

Over the past six months the agency has held formal and informal talks on the issue with several industry participants including mortgage bankers, megabanks with large MSR portfolios, and industry advisors who sell and hedge MSRs.

The regulator of Fannie and Freddie says commentators “expressed concerns that certain changes in the mortgage servicing compensation structure—specifically, a reduced MSF—would result in further consolidation in the servicing industry.”

Those in favor of maintaining the status quo fear that “servicers without significant economies of scale would suffer if the servicing fee were significantly reduced,” the agency explains. “They extrapolated that the end result would likely be the elimination of small- and medium-sized servicing entities for whom servicing would no longer be profitable or viable.”

At this time it does not appear that FHFA is pushing any one idea particularly hard – though it’s concerned about the processing of delinquent loans, particularly in light of the robosigning scandals – and still has an open mind on the issue.

Meanwhile, regulators are keen to note that the industry is “virtually uniform in their support for bifurcating the selling and servicing representations and warranties.”

According to comments already received, mortgage professionals are worried about “the inability to split representations and warranties” which has become a hurdle to transfers of servicing portfolios, the agency says. “Successor servicers are reluctant to accept a transfer of servicing because of the requirement to accept the origination representations and warranties, and this hinders the transfer of servicing portfolios (and non-performing segments of servicing portfolios) in circumstances where a potential successor is concerned that a transferring servicer may have failed to meet required servicing performance standards.”

Daily Briefing | Tuesday, September 27, 2011

  • Mortgage Debt Will Continue to Fall

    Outstanding residential mortgage debt in the U.S. will continue to fall over the next three quarters before stabilizing in mid-year 2012, according to a new forecast from Freddie Mac.

  • FHFA OIG Faults Freddie on Repurchase Policy

    Freddie Mac’s restrictive repurchase review policy on defaulted loans may prevent the GSE from recouping “billions of dollars” in losses from lenders, according to a new investigative report from the Federal Housing Finance Agency.

  • CoreLogic: Shadow Inventory Continues to Slide

    The nation’s inventory of “shadow” homes fell to 1.6 million units in July, a 16% decline from six months ago, according to new figures released by CoreLogic, Santa Ana, Calif.

  • Mortgage Cooperative Wants End to Volume Discounts

    Lenders One, the largest mortgage cooperative in the U.S., is calling for the Federal Housing Finance Agency to end volume discounts on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac’s guarantee fees.

  • Moody’s Voices Concern on CRE Recovery

    Moody’s Investors Services sees no broad-based recovery in commercial real estate markets over the next year due to weakness in demand and what it calls “diminished lending.”

  • FHFA Discussion Paper on Servicing Fees Imminent

    The Federal Housing Finance Agency as early as this week may release a new discussion paper on restructuring servicing compensation for GSE loans while seeking a new round of public comments on proposed changes.

  • A Gain for the SP HPI, But Firm Cautions Against Optimism

    Home prices rose almost 1% in July following a 1.2% increase in June, according to the new Standard Poor’s/Case-Shiller house price index.

  • OCC Tightens Its Grip Following OTS Lapses

    A growing list of failed thrift reports is helping the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency learn how to avoid the mistakes made by the Office of Thrift Supervision.

Leave a Reply