MERS Building Case Law in Oregon

Mortgage & Real Estate

A U.S. District Court judge in Oregon issued a pair of rulings in favor of Merscorp subsidiary Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc., but it remains unclear how those rulings will impact MERS’ appeal of a third case where a second federal judge vacated an Oregon borrower’s nonjudicial foreclosure.

Like what you see? Click here to sign up for a National Mortgage News free trial and daily newsletter to get the latest feature stories, news headlines, data, and in-depth analysis on the issues impacting the mortgage industry.

Judge Michael Mosman’s Aug. 1 decision in Beyer v. Bank of America et al. dismissed a couple’s attempts to block the foreclosure of their home and ruled that MERS is a proper beneficiary of the trust deed and authorized to assign it out of the name of MERS and into the name of the servicer.

Mosman used the same legal grounds in his Aug. 8 decision in Neilson v. Wells Fargo Bank, NA, et al., where he struck down the borrower’s similar claim that MERS was not a beneficiary capable of assigning the trust deed, and granted a motion for summary judgment to dismiss the borrower’s suit.

“This is another federal court ruling in Oregon affirming MERS’ business model and upholding MERS’ rights as the beneficiary,” Janis Smith, Merscorp vice president of corporate communications said in a press statement.

MERS will use those decisions in its U.S. Circuit Court appeal of federal Judge Owen Panner’s May 25 ruling that Bank of America, MERS Inc. and Northwest Trustee Services violated the Oregon Trust Deed Act by failing to record all assignments of mortgage when the note changed hands.

“[W]e will argue for a similar interpretation of Oregon law as the Court’s interpretation here in Neilson,” Smith said.

But in that case, Panner did not question MERS’ ability to transfer the deed trust, but rather interpreted state law to require that assignments should have also been filed the three times that the note changed hands in order for Bank of America and Northwest Trustee to use the state’s nonjudicial foreclosure process.

In rendering his decision, Panner ordered the defendants to submit a document, the “MIN Summary and Milestones,” which details the changes in note ownership that were tracked on the MERS System with the loan’s MIN, or mortgage identification number.

In his review of the defendants’ chain of title data, Panner noted a gap from when the loan was originated by a correspondent lender and registered on the MERS System. In addition, Northwest Trustee Services admitted that documents related to the trust and foreclosure were recorded out-of-order.

Panner called the defendants’ document review rushed, adding, “The ‘out-of-order’ recordings demonstrate problems, not atypical in my view, often caused by foreclosing parties rushing to expedite nonjudicial foreclosures.”

“Foreclosure by advertisement and sale, which is designed to take place outside of any judicial review, necessarily relies on the foreclosing party to accurately review and assess its own authority to foreclose,” Panner also wrote.

“The MERS system raises serious concerns regarding the appropriateness and validity of foreclosure by advertisement and sale outside of any judicial proceeding.”

Daily Briefing | Friday, August 26, 2011

  • Nonbanks Tap Warehouse Lenders for More Credit

    Not only are residential loan applications booming, but nonbanks increasingly are tapping their warehouse providers for additional credit.

  • Freddie Delays Reference Bill Auction Due to Hurricane Irene

    Freddie Mac said Friday it would delay its regularly scheduled Reference Bills auction announcement until Monday due to anticipation that Hurricane Irene could have an effect on capital market participants in New York and other parts of the East Coast.

  • Number of Maturing CMBS Loans May Decline Next Year

    Fewer U.S. commercial mortgage-backed securities loans are slated to come due in 2012 than this year, according to a Fitch report Friday.

  • Commercial RE Origination Volumes Up Nicely in 2Q, PNC a Standout

    Although residential origination volumes swooned in the second quarter, commercial mortgage production picked up nicely at many firms.

  • Fed Chief Thinks ‘Pro-Active’ Housing Policy May be Needed

    Pro-active housing policies may be needed to spur a recovery in the housing sector, according to Federal Reserve Board chairman Ben Bernanke.

  • California’s Sen. Boxer Wants FHFA to Aid in Underwater Refi Effort

    Senator Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., is pressing the GSE regulator to adopt several changes to the Home Affordable Refinancing Program, allowing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to refinance more underwater borrowers.

  • Massachusetts Home Sales Spike in July

    After five straight months where home sales plunged in Massachusetts compared to 2010, there are signs of a possible recovery in July 2011.

  • Buffett’s ‘Save’ of B of A Will Not Come Cheap for the Bank

    Warren Buffett’s $5 billion public vote of confidence in Bank of America, happily for him, does not require actual confidence. The terms of the legendary investor’s deal, which grants Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway Inc. $5 billion in perpetual preferred stock and warrants to buy B of A stock at just over $7 a share, include no lockup period.

  • 3Point Asset Management Hires Arch Bay Executive

    3Point Asset Management, Irvine, Calif., has hired Ron Millar as AVP in charge of sales and training.

  • Fed Chairman Sees Housing Stabilizing Over the Medium Term

    Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke criticized policymakers Friday for the political wrangling over raising the country’s debt limit, and warned that more such events could do even greater harm to the economy.

Leave a Reply