Robo-Signing Redux: Servicers Still Fabricating Foreclosure Docs


Some of the largest mortgage servicers are still fabricating documents that should have been signed years ago and submitting them as evidence to foreclose on homeowners.

Like what you see? Click here to sign up for a National Mortgage News free trial and daily newsletter to get the latest feature stories, news headlines, data, and in-depth analysis on the issues impacting the mortgage industry.

The practice continues nearly a year after the companies were caught cutting corners in the robo-signing scandal and about six months after the industry began negotiating a settlement with state attorneys general investigating loan-servicing abuses.

Several dozen documents reviewed by American Banker show that as recently as August some of the largest U.S. banks, including Bank of America Corp., Wells Fargo Co., Ally Financial Inc., and OneWest Financial Inc., were essentially backdating paperwork necessary to support their right to foreclose.

Some of documents reviewed by American Banker included signatures by current bank employees claiming to represent lenders that no longer exist. (American Banker is a sister publication to National Mortgage News.)

Many banks are missing the original papers from when they securitized the mortgages, in some cases as long ago as 2005 and 2006, according to plaintiffs’ lawyers. They and some industry members say the related mortgage assignments, showing transfers from one lender to another, should have been completed and filed with document custodians at the time of transfer.

“It’s one thing to not have the documents you’re supposed to have even though you told investors and the SEC you had them,” says Lynn E. Szymoniak, a plaintiff’s lawyer in West Palm Beach, Fla. “But they’re making up new documents.”

The banks argue that creating such documents is a routine business practice that simply “memorializes” actions that should have occurred years before. Some courts have endorsed that view, but others, such as the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, have found that this amounts to a lack of sufficient evidence and renders foreclosures invalid.

According to a document submitted in a Florida court by Bank of America Corp., bank assistant vice president Sandra Juarez signed a mortgage assignment on July 29 of this year that purported to transfer ownership of a mortgage from New Century Mortgage Corp. to a trustee, Deutsche Bank. Two problems with that: New Century, a subprime lender, went bankrupt in 2007; and the Deutsche Bank trust that purported to hold the loan was created for a securitization completed in 2006 — about five years before Juarez signed it over to the trust. (Bank of America, as the servicer of the loan, was seeking to foreclose on behalf of the trust and its bondholders.)

Most of the pooling and servicing agreements governing securitizations require a complete chain of endorsements. This means the promissory note (the piece of paper the borrower signs promising to pay the loan) and all intervening mortgage assignments showing transfers from one lender to another must be delivered to a trust within 60 days of the securitization closing date.

Jumana Bauwens, a spokeswoman for B of A, says such mortgage assignments are simply “procedural steps” to prove to a court that a trust has the right to foreclose on a borrower. In the Juarez case, B of A had power of attorney to sign on New Century’s behalf, she says.

But other mortgage industry members argue that the burden of proof is on the banks to show their legal right to enforce a debt, and that servicers are supposed to audit the loan before proceeding with a foreclosure.

“They’re supposed to make sure the trust is the correct trust, that the loan was properly assigned to the trust and that the debtor is genuinely in default,” says Michael Olenick, the chief executive of Legalprise Inc., a West Palm Beach, Fla., research firm that tracks foreclosure filings and other court records for attorneys.

Several other documents reviewed this month by American Banker were signed in July by Tonya Hopkins, who identified herself as an assistant secretary for Sand Canyon Mortgage, also known as Option One Mortgage Corp., the former subprime lending unit of HR Block Inc.

Sand Canyon quit the mortgage business in 2009 and sold the loans to American Home Mortgage Servicing Inc., where Hopkins now works — but she still signed the documents as an officer of Sand Canyon. An HR Block spokesman calls Sand Canyon a “discontinued business.”

Philippa Brown, a spokeswoman for American Home, says the transfer of the loan took place at the closing of the securitization in 2006 and the assignment that was recorded in 2010 was a “confirmatory assignment, memorializing the transfer that had previously occurred while Sand Canyon was still in business.”

She adds, “The practice of executing assignments to confirm for the public record that mortgages were previously assigned to the trust reflects standard industry practice.”

In another document, Wells Fargo assistant secretary Nancy D. Sorensen recently acted as a nominee of Fremont Investment and Loan, which went out of business in 2008. On Aug. 11 of this year, she assigned a mortgage from the Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems registry on behalf of Fremont to a Deutsche Bank trust — for a bond issue that was completed in 2006.

Wells Fargo spokesman Tom Goyda says the document is “a routine and fully authorized assignment of the [mortgage] note,” on behalf of Fremont “and its successors.”

Daily Briefing | Wednesday, August 31, 2011

  • B of A to Sell Correspondent Unit, Keep Warehouse

    After months of rumors, Bank of America made it official Wednesday morning, saying it would exit the correspondent mortgage space, where it ranks second nationwide.

  • CoreLogic: Home Prices Rise Ever So Slightly

    Home prices rose in July for the fourth consecutive month, according to CoreLogic, which tracks the market through its house price index.

  • Radian Exec Leaves to Head Hope LoanPort

    Radian Guaranty executive Camillo Melchiorre will leave his post as senior vice president of loss management to serve as president and CEO of mortgage technology nonprofit Hope LoanPort, effective Sept. 1.

  • SEC is Sniffing Around Mortgage REITs

    The Securities and Exchange Commission believes that mortgage real estate investment trusts are beginning to look more like mutual funds and has initiated a review of their exemption from the Investment Company Act.

  • Independent MBs Post Stronger Profit Margins, But…

    Independent mortgage banking firms made an average profit of $575 per origination in the second quarter, a 66% gain compared to 1Q — but a significant decline from two years ago when the average gain was $1,358.

  • LPS: Foreclosure Timeline Sets Another Record at 599 Days

    A payment has not been made on the average loan in foreclosure in 599 days, up from 587 the previous month, according to Lender Processing Services Inc.’s latest monthly Mortgage Monitor report.

  • Extension of Flood Insurance a Concern Once Again

    Congress begins its fall session on Tuesday and lawmakers will have only a few weeks to act before the authority of the Federal Emergency Management Agency to issue new flood insurance policies expires on Sept. 30.

  • LPS Markets Hybrid Valuations to Default Industry

    Lender Processing Services is now marketing its hybrid valuation service to owners of distressed property portfolios as an alternative to traditional broker price opinions.

  • MBA Index Shows Apps Dropping by About 10%

    Mortgage applications dropped 9.6% on a seasonally adjusted basis last week, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association’s weekly mortgage applications survey.

  • B of A’s Financial Advisory Expansion to Include Mortgage Specialists

    Bank of America is hiring financial advisors, including mortgage specialists, as it expands its network of high tech “specialty stores” for customers with $50,000 to $250,000 in “investable assets.”

  • Kinecta Allows Use of Assets for Jumbo Qualification

    Kinecta Federal Credit Union has launched a jumbo loan program for high net worth borrowers that allows them to use a percentage of their assets in certain other financial products to help them qualify for hybrid adjustable-rate mortgages from $417,001 to $3 million in size.

Leave a Reply