The Departments of Treasury and Housing and Urban Development (HUD)
released the August edition of their Housing Scorecard on Friday which painted
a picture of slowly increasing home prices and decreasing foreclosures while
The Scorecard, issued jointly by the Departments of
Treasury and Housing and Urban Development (HUD) is largely a recap of data
released by other sources such as the Census Bureau, SP Case-Schiller,
RealtyTrac and the National Association of Realtors. Much of the housing data is information that
we have previously covered.
The Housing Scorecard includes by reference the monthly report on the
Making Home Affordable Program (MHA, formerly known as HAMP) which is augmented
this month with detailed assessments of the 10 largest mortgage servicers
participating in MHA.
Much of the criticism of MHA, which started in April of 2009 as a joint
initiative of HUD and Treasury, has centered on the performance of mortgage
servicers. They are responsible for
identifying delinquent borrowers who are potential program participants,
contacting and qualifying them for a three-month trial program and then
converting those borrowers who successfully complete the trial into a permanent
loan modification. Servicers have been
faulted for failing to appropriately qualify borrowers, losing documents
supplied by the borrowers, failing to communicate with clients, and extremely long
delays in converting borrowers or failing to convert them at all.
Treasury and HUD have been attempting to improve servicer performance and
recently named Freddie Mac as compliance agent for the program. Freddie has created a separate division, MHA-Compliance
(MHA-C) to evaluate a range of servicer activities for compliance with MHA
guidelines. Servicers are evaluated on three
performance criteria; identifying and contacting homeowners, homeowner
evaluation and assistance, and program management, reporting and
governance. In addition, Freddie Mac
looked at such criteria as the length of time homeowners spent in various
stages of remediation and the servicers’ handling of documents. Servicers’ performance was evaluated in
comparison to the best servicer performance and the worst servicer performance
for each metric.
In June, the first time the assessments were made public, all ten of the
major servicers were found wanting and four were identified as needing substantial
improvement; three of those, J.P. Morgan Chase Bank, Wells Fargo Bank, and Bank
of America had financial incentives withheld for the first quarter of 2011 and
until the specified improvements were made.
The current assessment report, covering the second quarter, still found problems
with the operations of every servicer.
Two servicers needed minor improvements, and five, including Wells
Fargo, needed moderate changes. J.P. Morgan and Bank of America were again found
to be in need of substantial improvements and second quarter incentives have
Bank of America, for example, was found to have the worst performance of
all servicers in three of four metrics; its conversion rate, the average number
of calendar days required to resolve escalated cases, and the percent of
missing modification status reports.
J.P. Morgan performed well below par on two of the four metrics.
“While tens of thousands of additional
homeowners benefit from the Administration’s programs each month, we need to
keep the pressure on servicers to effectively assist those homeowners who are
still struggling and eligible for assistance,” said Treasury Assistant
Secretary for Financial Stability Tim Massad. “These assessments provide an
unprecedented level of information about servicer performance and are designed
to help more eligible homeowners walk away from this process with better
MHA also reports that it has completed 28,328 permanent modifications
since the June report for a total of 791,399 over the life of the program. An additional 22,079 trials have been started
for a total of 1,892,006 and 106,078 borrowers remained in trial status at the
end of July.
The average length of the trial period for those who convert to a
permanent modification has decreased from 5.3 months for trials started before
June 1, 2010 when the program underwent substantial revision to a duration of
3.5 months for trials started after that date.
The Second Lien Modification Program which provides assistance to
homeowner in a first lien modification program has now completed modifications
on 32,172 second liens and partially extinguished 1,356.
Home Affordable Foreclosure Alternatives offers incentives for homeowners
who wish to exit their homes through a short sale or deed-in-lieu of
foreclosure. It has now effectuated 12,514
short sales and 374 deeds-in-lieu out of 25,716 homeowners who have entered the